One of my upcoming grooms, Mike, was on the phone in a panic. I had already met with him and Suzy. Their deposit was paid and ceremony scripted. Wedding plans for the following month were moving forward in earnest: invitations ready, family and friends preparing to come. Travel arrangements were also made for the couple’s honeymoon trip overseas. Now, suddenly, they had a big problem. Suzy was planning to change her last name, so Mike had gone ahead and purchased her airline ticket in her new, married name. But then they realized that the name on her ID, including her passport, had to match the airline ticket. As they found out, reissuing a passport may take several weeks. Unfortunately, they had several days, not weeks between the ceremony and their trip. The airline refused to reissue her ticket under her old name, quoting Patriot Act law. Buying a new ticket was not in their budget. Mike’s questions to me: Would I be able to marry them early so she could change her name and avoid a travel disaster? Furthermore, could they still go forward with my officiating the later wedding they’d planned, even if they were already married? My answer of, “Yes,” and “Yes,” to both questions was a great relief to them. And on their big day when Mike and Suzy said their I do’s before friends and family, no one knew I’d already pronounced them husband and wife a month earlier.
Though the reasons are usually different from Mike and Suzy’s, I’ve seen a growing phenomenon of one couple, two weddings. One will be a private legal ceremony, the other a much larger “social” wedding. The interval between may stretch from several weeks or months to sometimes as much as a year. The reason for two weddings? Most often it is to gain insurance, military, or tax benefits without delay. Alternatively, it can be an issue of timing and logistics, i.e., getting family that live in different geographical locations all together in one place at the same time. One of my couples who was intimidated about the legal paperwork simply wanted it out of the way so there would be one less thing to worry about at their big wedding.
Sometimes family is informed of the true story and sometimes not. I don’t have a problem with keeping the couple’s “secret.” However, this can create a gray area with potential for problems, especially of legal problems. This is definitely something a couple will want to consider if they are choosing to delay an official marriage. What if, God forbid, someone falls ill or something happens to one of both before a legally recognized marriage takes place? If the family doesn’t know, they may go hunting for a marriage record that doesn’t exist. There could be financial and inheritance issues as well. This is something a couple should take up with legal counsel.
If I’m called upon to keep such a secret, I do want to at least know about it in advance. One couple certainly threw me a curve ball that left me with an ethical dilemma. They had not given any indication of anything unusual during our initial meeting. They had paid their deposit and approved the ceremony I’d prepared for them. When I arrived on their wedding day, I asked to see the license, which is standard procedure, to check the dates and make sure all is in order. And it was—until the groom told me they wanted to file their license, themselves. I declined, explaining it was my responsibility and part of my job to file it. Then we had a problem. They confessed to me that they weren’t planning to file it, after all. For reasons they never explained to me, they could not go through with a legal marriage at that time, but had obviously purchased the license as a ruse to make their family think they were.
I take a fairly broad view of the term marriage. To me, a marriage of the heart is still a marriage and is deserving of a celebration, even a public declaration and ceremony, if that’s what a couple wants. If for whatever reason they choose to forego the piece of paper, it’s up to them to be aware of the legal ramifications. And I don’t mind if there is a time lag between a marriage of the heart and the marriage on record at the courthouse. As long as I’m following the laws of my state and the dictates of my conscience, I believe in helping a couple achieve whatever kind of union they wish. On the other hand, this particular couple had not only misled me, but had in effect made me co-conspirator in their plan to deceive their family—who, by the way, were all waiting in their seats for the nuptials to begin while we were sorting things out in the hallway. Needless to say, I was not a happy camper. I would have been within my rights to walk out and leave them to explain to their family why there would not be a wedding that day. Had I been a stickler for doing things by the book, I would have done just that.
I chose to handle the situation differently. First of all I made it clear to them that they had put me in a moral quandary and really should have clued me into their situation up front. That said, I went on to explain that for me, it boils down to a matter of a couple’s intent. I asked them: Is it truly their intent to be married, and do they plan to make it legal when they are able? “Yes,” and “Yes!” They answered. On that basis I agreed to go forward with their ceremony (minus any legal language such as references to the power vested in me by the State). Were they telling the truth? I figure that’s between them and their conscience.
Another category of one couple, two weddings that is worth mentioning: Exes who re-marry each other. I’ve performed re-marriage ceremonies for several couples who for one reason or another things didn’t work out the first time around. The tone for these kinds of weddings feels more familiar and comfortable. These individuals know each other well, including their darker sides. One would hope they are really the right couple, but that before, it was just the wrong time. Now they are older and most likely wiser. They may have learned lessons that only experience and time can teach. I hope so. And I wish for them the same as I wish for all my couples: many years of wedded bliss and all the happiness their two hearts can hold.
Rev. Leah Light
www.weddedyourway.com
Tags:marriage license minister officiant wedding ceremony Wedding planning
If you enjoyed this post, make sure you subscribe to my RSS feed!